When I was in residency something-teen years ago, I had a problem with plantar fasciitis. It's basically an issue that causes inflammation and pain in the heel through the arch of the foot. It's usually a challenge to treat, given that it takes a long time of daily stretches, ice and occasionally night splints. I am pretty sure that 3 years of spending quite a bit of my time on my feet wearing what probably weren't the most supportive shoes caused it. Once I got into private practice and wasn't walking the hospitals for hours at a time or standing in surgeries and so on, it resolved. Oh, that and the daily stretching, icing and night splints.
Anyway, about 2 weeks into the walking, my old friend was back. My arches hurt, my heels hurt, even my ankle hurt. I assumed the ankle was just the tweaking of an old injury. I've turned my ankles what feels like 100 times. Four or five days of wearing an ankle splint and the ankle was back to solid. The heels and arches? Not so much.
So, I started looking at my shoes. I'm a shoe girl. I have lots of shoes. My husband finds it crazy, since I pretty much wear the same 3 or 4 pair of shoes all the time. And him? He's got 3 pair: a pair of sandals for summer, some boots for winter and some dress shoes that he's probably had for 15 years. I have sneakers, running shoes, walking shoes, dress shoes, work shoes, boots, sandals, strappy shoes, well, you get the idea.
I started digging out all of the vaguely athletic shoes I own. These vary from shoes I bought for trips, for hobbies, because they were cute, whatever. Most of them were buried under other, more professional shoes. I sort of gave up wearing sneakers for much, given that I had discovered the Chaco sandals for summer active wear, and really the only time I used the athletic shoes was for walking or when I flirted with running.
So I started with the Brooks. The main problem I had with them was that they're old. Like almost 10 years old. Somehow my feet have changed enough and these shoes are old enough, they were pinching the backs of my heels and my achilles tendon. After a day of wearing them at work, not even on the treadmill, I had more or less constant pain. They got tossed on to the Goodwill pile.

So, I broke down. I went to the sporting goods store. The local one nearest my work is Dick's. Or, as we like to call them, Richard's. You know, to keep it family safe. Now I know that Richard's is not staffed with experienced runners. At noon on a May weekday, the chances are, it's not really going to be manned by running experts who will measure my shoe, watch me walk, assess whether I pronate or supinate, and so on. I already knew a lot of that stuff based on buying the Brooks at Ninth St. Active Feet in Durham. I got a guy who asked me what I'd like, he pointed me at the shoes on sale (I didn't want to spend a fortune), and I tried them on myself, walked around the place, decided out of the 3 pairs I tried that I liked the Saucony Cohesion, and bought them. I still spent too much on them, but it was under $70, so no problem. I liked the shoes. I liked how they felt. But like the Asics, after a while, my arches and heels started hurting again. So close, but no cigar for the standing pair of shoes for wearing.
Realizing that I had bought a pair of the Saucony Kinvaras a couple of years ago for the Couch to 5k running program, I dug them out. When I got them initially, I didn't like the way they fit. I remember them being too small. Once I had them out and tried them again, they seemed to fit fine. Maybe my toes lost weight? The thing I love about these shoes? They are light. I mean SUPER light. Like, both of them together weigh less than a pound. The mesh keeps my feet super cool. They are super flexible in the sole. They have a nice, ridged arch support, which felt great. At first. Then after about an hour and a half at any speed over 1.4 MPH, my arches started to ache, and how. Once again, disappointment came in the form of my shoes.

Then, earlier this week, Noah was bragging about a new pair of Skechers he picked up. They had memory foam insoles. They were comfortable and affordable (he had gotten a pair of Saucony running shoes, also at 9th Street Active Feet, after being measured and evaluated by an actual runner who was trained to put people in the right shoes). He liked his shoes he had been using, but he had started to subscribe to my theory: shoe switching. My best solution for the shoe issue was shoe rotation. I don't mean wearing one pair one day and another pair another day. I mean wearing one sort of shoe to work (usually Danskos or Clarks), slipping in to a pair of runners when I get home and then changing in a couple of hours. Some particularly long walking days, I would change shoes 3 or 4 times. In his search for a similar pair of shoes to swap out with his new running shoes (but ones that cost less than $170), he had found these memory foam insoled sport shoes.
They came today. They're bright (although I have the option for blue laces, but what's the point of that?!?), they're light, and they're comfy. I had to try them on twice, since the first time I put them on, I forgot to take out the cardboard insert on the bottom of them. They have a built up heel, which takes a little getting used to, but that isn't as much of a problem as I was fearing it would be. The raised heel seems to help with the PF pain, without putting too much pressure on my arches.
I think these shoes aren't going to be a miracle solution. I mean, I like them, and I like them more than any of the others at this point. However, I'm still fairly convinced that I'll need to stick with the shoe rotation approach. The real challenge will be when I get into the bed tonight: how long will my feet ache before I fall asleep. I am hoping the memory foam, and the experimentation with more compressive socks will be the ticket.
Either way, I'm on my 2nd mile today, with probably 2 more to go, and they're holding up pretty swell so far.